The White Box · AI audit · Sample report
AI audit reportKestrel Lane Payroll
Fictional company. Kestrel Lane Payroll does not exist. Every name, number and finding below is invented to show what a TWB AI audit delivers.
- Company
- 80 people · Payroll and HR outsourcing · Singapore
- Clients
- 420 client companies, 3 of them regulated financial institutions
- Audit
- 12 Oct–23 Oct 2026 · 10 working days
- Report date
- 26 Oct 2026
Part 1 of 7
The short version
You spend S$49,524 a year on AI across 17 tools. A third of it pays for seats nobody uses or for tools the company already has. Client payroll data reaches places the company does not control, and one client has been given a wrong answer about it. Most of this can be fixed within 90 days; the largest saving comes at the Copilot renewal in March.
33% of your AI spend. S$10,440 of it starts within 90 days; the rest at the Copilot renewal in March.
Client payroll data in personal AI accounts, an outside app that can send a manager’s email, an exposed key to payslip files, and a client told that no AI touches its data. All four within 30 days, starting this week.
of paid AI seats were used in the last 30 days. Accounting, which asked for access, has the fewest seats for its size.
Five things to do
This week, with your lawyer: decide whether client data has been exposed, which clients to tell and how to correct the March questionnaire answer. Save the logs before anything is deleted.
Close two open doors: remove the email assistant’s access, and replace the payslip assistant’s key with two company admins in charge.
Move everyone off personal AI accounts, and set one rule: no NRIC numbers, salaries, bank details or medical data in AI tools not approved for client data.
Stop paying for unused and duplicate AI: end 25 reimbursed plans, cut Grammarly before 20 November and renew Copilot at 22 seats in March.
Name an AI owner, and adopt a short AI policy, an approved-tools list and the register.
Covered: 17 AI tools · 80 staff · 12 months of spend · 7 areas · 25 findings (4 high, 12 medium, 9 low)
Part 2 of 7
Findings in seven areas
Each area gets a level from 0 to 3. Each finding gets a severity, a due date and, where it is about money, a yearly saving.
| Area | Now | In 90 days | Findings |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. AI register and shadow AI | 2 · Mostly | 1 medium2 low | |
| 2. Spend, licences and the 400% deduction | 3 · Fully | 3 medium4 low | |
| 3. Data and PDPA | 2 · Mostly | 1 high3 medium1 low | |
| 4. Access, integrations and agents | 2 · Mostly | 2 high1 medium | |
| 5. Usage and value | 2 · Mostly | 1 medium1 low | |
| 6. Policy, training and oversight | 2 · Mostly | 1 medium | |
| 7. Outside AI vendors and client questions | 2 · Mostly | 1 high2 medium1 low |
- 0 · None
- Nothing is in place, and nobody manages it.
- 1 · Started
- Something exists, but not as a system.
- 2 · Mostly
- Rules exist but are not followed everywhere.
- 3 · Fully
- In place, working and checked regularly.
Area 1
AI register and shadow AI
“Which AI tools do we really have?”
We found 17 AI tools. Management’s list had 8.
Management’s list had 8 of the 17 AI tools in use
The other 9 came from expense claims, apps staff approved in Microsoft 365, admin settings and the staff survey: personal ChatGPT Plus, Cursor, Perplexity and Otter plans; free personal AI apps; an AI email assistant; the OpenAI account behind the payslip assistant; and the AI features in Microsoft 365 Copilot Chat and Xero.
What to do. Adopt the register in Part 3 and check it every month. Every new AI tool goes through it.
- Evidence
- Microsoft 365 app approvals, Xero bills and expense claims, card statements, admin settings, staff survey.
- Basis
- MAS AI guidelines 4.2–4.7 (inventory) · ISO/IEC 42001 A.4 · NIST AI RMF GOVERN 1.6
Six tools have no owner inside the company
Nobody is responsible for their settings, seats or renewals. Four of them are paid through expense claims.
What to do. Name an owner for each tool in the register. The owner approves seats and checks each renewal.
- Evidence
- Interviews, register.
- Basis
- ISO/IEC 42001 A.3 (roles and responsibilities)
Built-in AI features are on for everyone, with no rules on their use
Microsoft 365 Copilot Chat, Notion AI, Canva’s AI tools, Zoom AI Companion and Xero’s AI features are switched on for all staff. Each sees the same data as the software it sits in, and nobody has decided who may use them or with what data.
What to do. List them in the register and decide, tool by tool, who may use them and with what data.
- Evidence
- Admin settings of each product (Zoom: one user’s settings, as admin access was not given).
- Basis
- MAS AI guidelines 4.2 (includes AI inside bought software)
Area 2
Spend, licences and the 400% deduction
“How much do we pay for AI, and how much do we waste?”
S$49,524 a year on AI. S$16,380 of it can stop.
26 of 40 Microsoft 365 Copilot seats were not used in the last 30 days
17 of them were not used at all in 90 days. Meanwhile five people in accounting asked for Copilot and did not get it.
What to do. Move five idle seats to accounting now. At the renewal on 1 March 2027, keep 22 seats: the 14 people using it, the 5 in accounting and 3 of the 9 who used it in the last 90 days but not the last 30. Seats can be cut only at renewal, so this is due later than other medium findings.
- Evidence
- Microsoft 365 Copilot usage report (30 and 90 days), licence list, Microsoft invoice.
The company reimburses 25 personal AI subscriptions
Otter (12 people), Perplexity (5), Cursor (4) and ChatGPT Plus (4) are claimed back every month. Each duplicates a tool the company already pays for, and none is under company control.
What to do. Stop reimbursing them from December and move these people to company seats (Part 6, action 5).
- Evidence
- Xero expense claims, 12 months.
Grammarly renews on 20 November for 10 seats; 3 are used
Copilot in Word and Outlook covers the same need for the staff who keep a Copilot seat.
What to do. Reduce the plan to 3 seats before the renewal date.
- Evidence
- Grammarly admin panel, invoice.
9 ChatGPT Business seats are idle; 4 belong to people who have left
Seats are not removed when someone leaves. At the same time, the survey shows 6 people in payroll operations paying for personal ChatGPT accounts.
What to do. Offer the idle seats to payroll operations now. Renew 27 seats instead of 30 on 12 January 2027, and add seat removal to the leaver checklist.
- Evidence
- ChatGPT Business members and activity, HR leaver list, staff survey.
Claude Team is billed monthly for 8 seats; 7 are used
Annual billing costs 20% less per seat for the same plan.
What to do. Switch to annual billing for 7 seats at the renewal on 5 December.
- Evidence
- Claude Team admin panel, invoices.
The OpenAI API account has no spend alerts and no cap
In August a test script left running for three days cost S$1,140. Automatic top-ups kept the credit flowing, and nobody noticed until the card statement.
What to do. Set email alerts on monthly spend (OpenAI bills in US dollars: about US$770, at 50%, 80% and 100%), cap or turn off automatic top-ups, and add a spending stop to test scripts (Part 6, action 2).
- Evidence
- OpenAI usage and cost export, billing settings.
Your accounts do not separate AI spend, which makes a 400% claim harder to support
AI tools are booked as general software. Part 5 separates them line by line, with the basis for each amount.
What to do. Send Part 5 to your tax adviser before you file for YA2027.
- Evidence
- Xero bills, vendor price pages.
- Basis
- IRAS e-Tax Guide on the Enterprise Innovation Scheme (31 Aug 2026), Annex F
Outside AI spend: 8 of 12 Canva seats are unused (S$1,040 a year). We note it here but do not count it in the savings.
Area 3
Data and PDPA
“Where does our data, and our clients’ data, go?”
Client employee data reaches tools the company does not control.
Client employee data goes into personal AI accounts
In the anonymous survey, 11 of 61 staff said they had pasted client employee data, such as names with salaries, NRIC numbers or medical leave, into a personal AI account in the last three months. 23 people use personal AI accounts for work; 9 of them pay for ChatGPT Plus.
Why it matters. These accounts are outside company control. Chats stay with the person when they leave, and depending on each person’s settings the vendor may use them to train its models. As your clients’ payroll processor under written contracts, you are likely a data intermediary under the PDPA, so you must protect this data and, if you have reason to believe a data breach has occurred, tell the client without undue delay.
What to do. This week, assess with your lawyer whether this is a data breach and which clients to tell (Part 6, action 1). Then offer a company AI seat to anyone using a personal account: idle ChatGPT and Copilot seats are available today, and Microsoft 365 Copilot Chat, which your licence includes, covers everyone else. Publish one rule: NRIC numbers, salaries, bank details and medical data never go into an AI tool that is not approved for client data. Add a browser or Microsoft 365 rule that blocks NRIC numbers on unapproved AI sites.
- Evidence
- Anonymous staff survey, Xero expense claims, interviews.
- Basis
- PDPA s.24 (protection) and s.26C(3)(a) (a data intermediary must tell its client about a breach) · PDPC Advisory Guidelines on GenAI (Jul 2026) 9.1, 9.3
Client payroll files are open to the whole company, and Copilot makes them easy to find
Three SharePoint sites with client payroll exports are shared with “Everyone except external users”. Anyone in the company could open them before; Copilot now brings them up in answer to a simple question.
What to do. Limit the three sites to the payroll team before you move Copilot seats around. Then check the other sites that are open to the whole company.
- Evidence
- SharePoint sharing settings (site names and permissions only).
- Basis
- PDPA s.24 · ISO/IEC 42001 A.7 (data for AI systems)
Personal meeting recorders join client calls
12 personal Otter accounts join calendar meetings automatically, including client payroll reviews. Recordings and transcripts sit in personal accounts on servers overseas and leave with the person.
What to do. Cancel these accounts (finding 2.2). Ask each owner to delete client-call recordings after saving the notes the client file needs. Use Copilot recaps in Teams or Zoom AI Companion under company settings.
- Evidence
- Expense claims, Microsoft 365 app approvals, staff survey.
- Basis
- PDPA s.26 (transfers abroad) for your own staff’s data, and your client contracts for client data · PDPC Advisory Guidelines on GenAI 9.3
The data protection policy does not mention AI
The policy dates from 2023. Staff have no written guidance on what data may go into AI tools, and the Data Protection Officer was not asked when AI tools were bought.
What to do. Add an AI section to the policy, with the five rules in area 6. Involve the Data Protection Officer in every new AI tool.
- Evidence
- Data Protection Policy (2023), interview with the COO, who is also the Data Protection Officer.
- Basis
- PDPA s.12 (policies) · PDPC Advisory Guidelines on GenAI 9.3–9.4
Zoom meeting summaries go to every participant, clients included
Zoom AI Companion is set to email its summary to all participants. A summary of an internal discussion can reach a client unreviewed.
What to do. Send summaries to the host only, who reviews them before sharing.
- Evidence
- One user’s Zoom settings (admin access was not given).
Area 4
Access, integrations and agents
“Who and what can act on the company’s behalf?”
Any employee can give an outside app access to company mail and files.
An AI email assistant can read, send and delete a manager’s email
On 14 May 2026 a sales manager approved a third-party AI email assistant with permission to read, send and delete mail and to read every file the manager can open. Nobody reviewed it, and its terms do not say where data is stored. Your Microsoft 365 settings let any employee approve apps like this: staff have approved 23 apps on their own, 7 of them AI tools.
Why it matters. An app that can send email as a manager can also send payment instructions. Access like this should be narrow and approved.
What to do. Remove this app’s access now and ask the manager what they need; Copilot in Outlook may cover it. Then require IT approval for any app that asks for access to mail, files or calendars.
- Evidence
- Microsoft Entra ID app consents and permissions.
- Basis
- IMDA Model AI Governance Framework for Agentic AI (2026) 2.1–2.2 · CSA Guidelines on Securing AI Systems
The payslip assistant’s key is in a shared note, and the account owner has left
The OpenAI API key sits in a OneNote page that 26 people can open. It was created in March 2025 and never changed. The account’s owner is a former employee who left in June 2026. The same key can download 1,214 files with payslip-style names that were uploaded for testing. We read the file names, not the files.
What to do. Replace the key now. Delete the test files only after the logs and the file list are saved for the breach assessment (Part 6, action 1), then make two company admins the owners. Keep keys in a password vault for system keys, and set the spend alerts in finding 2.6.
- Evidence
- OpenAI organisation settings, project file list (names only), OneNote sharing settings.
- Basis
- CSA Guidelines on Securing AI Systems · IMDA agentic AI framework (scoped keys) · PDPA s.24
The payslip assistant answers client employees without a human check
In a pilot with one client, the assistant replies directly to employees’ payslip questions. Nobody reviews the answers, and nobody has measured how often they are wrong.
What to do. Until accuracy is measured, route answers to payroll operations for approval, and keep a log of questions and answers.
- Evidence
- Interview with the tech lead, assistant configuration.
- Basis
- IMDA agentic AI framework 2.2 (points of human approval)
Area 5
Usage and value
“What does AI actually give us?”
53% of paid AI seats were used in the last 30 days.
| Team | People | Paid seats | Used in 30 days | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Payroll operations | 38 | 40 | 20 | |
| Accounting | 14 | 6 | 2 | |
| Sales and client success | 10 | 16 | 10 | |
| Technology | 6 | 16 | 12 | |
| Finance and admin | 5 | 5 | 2 | |
| HR | 3 | 3 | 1 | |
| Management | 4 | 8 | 3 | |
| All teams | 80 | 94 | 50 |
Accounting has the fewest seats for its size and the clearest need
Accounting has 6 seats for 14 people. Five of them asked for Copilot to draft month-end variance notes in Excel, which takes each about six hours a month. The survey shows three people in accounting using personal ChatGPT accounts in the meantime.
What to do. Give them five idle Copilot seats now (finding 2.1) and review their use after 60 days.
- Evidence
- Interviews, staff survey, Copilot licence list.
Nobody measures what AI saves, so we could not either
No team has a baseline. The best place to start is payroll operations: the helpdesk shows about 1,900 questions from client employees a month, with a median handling time of 14 minutes.
What to do. Pick two operations teams. Compare their handling and first-response times for the 30 days before and the 30 days after they move to company AI seats, then decide on more seats from the difference.
- Evidence
- Helpdesk export (ticket counts and times only).
- Basis
- NIST AI RMF MAP 3.1 (benefits) · MANAGE 1.1
Where AI can help most
- Replies to client employees’ payroll questionsPayroll operations
About 1,900 questions a month. Measure handling time before adding seats.
- Month-end variance notes in ExcelAccounting
5 people, about six hours each a month. Start with Copilot seats that are idle today.
- Proposals and prospect researchSales and client success
Already in daily use on ChatGPT Business. Drop the reimbursed Perplexity plans.
Area 6
Policy, training and oversight
“Do we have rules for AI, and do people follow them?”
One of six basics is in place, and only in part.
The MAS guidelines apply to financial institutions. We use their six basics as a benchmark because they suit any company, and your financial-institution clients may ask you similar questions.
| Basic | Today | Next step |
|---|---|---|
| A senior manager is accountable for AI oversight | Missing | Name the COO as AI owner |
| Rules on permitted and prohibited uses, including no client data in public AI tools, and on when a person must check AI output | Partly | Adopt the draft policy, and extend the payroll four-eyes check to AI-drafted replies and the payslip assistant |
| An approved list of AI tools and a way to request a new one | Missing | Approved tools come from the register; requests go to the AI owner |
| Staff know the AI rules | Missing | A 30-minute session for everyone by mid-January, then once a year |
| Regular checks that the rules are followed | Missing | A monthly register check against the policy |
| A regular review, and a review after any change, of whether AI use is still lower-risk | Missing | Review once a year, and whenever AI starts answering clients or their employees, as the payslip assistant now does |
There is no AI policy, no AI owner and no approved tool list
The only rule that touches AI is the payroll four-eyes check, which predates AI. Staff decide for themselves which tools to use and what to put in them.
What to do. Name the COO as AI owner. Adopt the two-page draft policy and the approved-tools list from the register. Give every employee a 30-minute session by mid-January.
- Evidence
- Company documents, interviews.
- Basis
- MAS AI guidelines 2.3–2.5 (used as a benchmark) · ISO/IEC 42001 A.2–A.3 · NIST AI RMF GOVERN 2
Five rules from the draft AI policy
- Use only the company’s approved AI tools for work. To add a tool, ask the AI owner.
- Never enter NRIC numbers, salaries, bank details or medical information into an AI tool unless it is approved for client data.
- A person checks every AI-drafted message before it goes to a client or a client’s employee.
- Do not connect an AI app to your work email, files or calendar without IT approval.
- If client data goes into the wrong tool, tell the Data Protection Officer the same day.
Area 7
Outside AI vendors and client questions
“Are we ready when a client asks how we use AI?”
Two financial-institution clients asked about AI this year. One was given an answer the survey contradicts.
A client was told that no AI is used with its data
In March 2026 a fund-management client sent a supplier questionnaire. The answer given was “No AI tools are used with client data”. The survey shows otherwise (finding 3.1).
Why it matters. A wrong answer to a regulated client can cost you the client. MAS’s AI guidelines take effect in October 2027 and expect financial institutions to oversee the AI their service providers use, so the question will come again.
What to do. Speak to your lawyer this week (Part 6, action 1) and fix finding 3.1 in parallel. Then send the client an accurate answer, as your lawyer advises.
- Evidence
- Client questionnaire and the answer sent.
- Basis
- MAS AI guidelines 5.10–5.11 (third-party AI)
Client questions about AI take weeks to answer, and nobody checks the answers
A second client’s questionnaire took three weeks. Answers are written from scratch each time by whoever receives the question.
What to do. Keep an answer pack ready: 12 common questions with your answers, the evidence behind them and one person who checks every answer before it goes out.
- Evidence
- Two client questionnaires and the answers sent, interviews.
- Basis
- MAS AI guidelines 5.10–5.11 (what financial-institution clients will ask) · ISO/IEC 42001 A.8
Vendor data terms and safeguards for transfers abroad are not on file
The business terms of ChatGPT Business, Claude Team and the OpenAI API say business data is not used for training by default, and their data processing terms apply automatically. Nobody has read or filed them, so nobody can say where data is stored or for how long. The meeting recorders and the email assistant run on personal terms only.
What to do. File the data processing terms of every approved vendor and keep one page per vendor: where data is stored, the training setting, how long data is kept and the companies they pass it to. Drop tools that cannot provide them.
- Evidence
- Vendor terms, admin settings.
- Basis
- PDPA s.26 (transfers abroad) for your own staff’s data, and your client contracts for client data · ISO/IEC 42001 A.10 (third parties)
The payslip assistant depends on one model, and change notices go to a former employee
If the provider retires the model or changes its price, the notice goes to the former owner’s mailbox. No alternative has been tested.
What to do. Once two company admins own the account (Part 6, action 2), record the model version in the register and test one alternative model.
- Evidence
- OpenAI organisation settings.
- Basis
- NIST AI RMF GOVERN 6.2 (third-party contingency) · ISO/IEC 42001 A.10
Part 3 of 7
AI register
Every AI tool in use, who owns it, what data it can see and whether client data may go into it. Six have no owner; four of those are paid through expense claims.
| Tool | Used for | Owner | Data it can see | Plan and seats | Status | Client data | Risk |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Microsoft 365 Copilot | Drafting, summaries, Excel | IT lead | Mail, files and chats the user can open | Business · 40 seats, 14 used | Approved | After 3.2 | Medium3.2 |
| Microsoft 365 Copilot Chat | Quick questions | IT lead | What users paste in | Included in Microsoft 365 · all staff | Built in | Yes | Low |
| ChatGPT Business | Client replies, payroll rules, proposals | COO | What users paste or upload | Business · 30 seats, 21 used | Approved | After 7.3 | Medium2.4 |
| ChatGPT Plus (personal) | Same as ChatGPT Business | No owner | Client employee data (survey) | Personal · 9 people, 4 reimbursed | Reimbursed | No | High3.1 |
| Claude Team | Code, internal documents | Tech lead | Source code, internal documents | Team, monthly · 8 seats, 7 used | Approved | No | Low2.5 |
| GitHub Copilot | Code | Tech lead | Source code | Business · 6 seats, 5 used | Approved | No | Low |
| Cursor (personal) | Code | No owner | Source code | Personal · 4 reimbursed | Reimbursed | No | Medium2.2 |
| Perplexity (personal) | Prospect research | No owner | Prospect names and notes | Personal · 5 reimbursed | Reimbursed | No | Low2.2 |
| Otter (personal) | Meeting notes | No owner | Recordings of internal and client calls | Personal · 12 reimbursed | Reimbursed | No | Medium3.3 |
| Grammarly | Writing | Head of payroll operations | Text typed in the browser | Pro · 10 seats, 3 used | Approved | No | Low2.3 |
| Notion AI | Documents, notes | Tech lead | Notion pages | Included in Business · 20 members, 9 use AI | Built in | No | Low |
| Canva AI tools | Marketing images | Sales manager | Brand files | Included in Teams · 12 seats, 4 used | Built in | No | Low |
| Zoom AI Companion | Meeting summaries | IT lead | Zoom meetings | Included in Zoom | Built in | After 3.5 | Low3.5 |
| Xero AI features | Bookkeeping | Finance manager | Client ledgers | Included in Xero | Built in | Yes, inside Xero | Low |
| OpenAI API · payslip assistant | Answers client employees’ payslip questions (pilot) | Tech lead | Payslips, client payroll policies | Billed by use · S$9,780 a year | Built in-house | After 4.2, 4.3 | High4.2 |
| AI email assistant (third-party) | Email drafting | No owner | One manager’s mail and files | Personal sign-up | Not approved | No | High4.1 |
| Personal free AI apps | Various | No owner | Whatever users paste in | Free · 14 people | Shadow AI | No | High3.1 |
Client data: whether client employee data may go into the tool under the draft AI policy. “After” means once that finding is fixed.
Apps staff approved in Microsoft 365
23 outside apps, 7 of them AI tools. The riskiest can read and send a manager’s mail (finding 4.1); 8 more can read calendars or contacts, or open the user’s own files. We read app names and permissions, not mail or files.
| App | AI tool | People | What it can do | Risk | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AI email assistant (name withheld) | Yes, by name | 1 | Can send email as the user; Can change or delete mail; Can read any file the user can open; Keeps access until someone removes it; Publisher not verified by Microsoft | High | Remove access; require admin approval for apps like this |
| Otter.ai | Otter | 12 | Can read the calendar; Keeps access until someone removes it | Medium | Confirm who uses it and why |
| Notion | Notion AI | 5 | Can read the calendar; Keeps access until someone removes it | Medium | Confirm who uses it and why |
| Zoom | — | 18 | Can change calendar events; Keeps access until someone removes it | Medium | Confirm who uses it and why |
| Adobe Acrobat | — | 5 | Can open the user’s own files; Keeps access until someone removes it | Medium | Confirm who uses it and why |
| Calendly | — | 4 | Can change calendar events; Keeps access until someone removes it | Medium | Confirm who uses it and why |
| — | 4 | Can read contacts | Medium | Confirm who uses it and why | |
| Lucidchart | — | 2 | Can open the user’s own files; Keeps access until someone removes it | Medium | Confirm who uses it and why |
| Mailchimp | — | 1 | Can read contacts; Keeps access until someone removes it | Medium | Confirm who uses it and why |
| ChatGPT | ChatGPT | 6 | Sign-in only | Low | No action needed |
| Perplexity | Perplexity | 5 | Sign-in only | Low | No action needed |
| Claude | Claude | 3 | Sign-in only | Low | No action needed |
| Grammarly | Grammarly | 3 | Sign-in only | Low | No action needed |
Sign-in only, no action needed: DocuSign, Miro, Xero, Asana, Dropbox, Trello, HubSpot, Smartsheet, SurveyMonkey, Typeform.
Part 4 of 7
Renewal calendar
What renews in the next 12 months, and what to decide before each date. Seats can usually be cut only at renewal, so the dates matter.
- Nov 202620 Grammarly
- Dec5 Claude
- Jan 20278 Canva12 ChatGPT
- Feb
- Mar1 Copilot
- Apr15 Zoom
- May
- Jun1 Notion
- Jul
- Aug
- Sep
- Oct
| Renews | Tool | Terms | Cost | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 20 Nov 2026 | Grammarly Pro | Annual · 10 seats | S$1,920 | Decide by 13 Nov: renew 3 seats2.3 |
| 5 Dec 2026 | Claude Team | Monthly · 8 seats | S$260 a month | Switch to annual billing for 7 seats2.5 |
| 8 Jan 2027 | Canva Teams | Annual · 12 seats | S$1,560 | Renew 4 seats (outside AI spend) |
| 12 Jan 2027 | ChatGPT Business | Annual · 30 seats | S$9,360 | Decide by 5 Jan: renew 27 seats2.4 |
| 1 Mar 2027 | Microsoft 365 Copilot Business | Annual · 40 seats | S$13,200 | Decide by 15 Feb: renew 22 seats2.1 |
| 15 Apr 2027 | Zoom Workplace (AI Companion included) | Annual | No AI charge | Check summary settings first3.5 |
| 1 Jun 2027 | Notion Business (Notion AI included) | Annual · 20 members | S$6,240 | Keep Business only if AI use holds (9 of 20 today) |
Billed every month
Part 5 of 7
AI spend for your tax adviser
Singapore’s Enterprise Innovation Scheme allows a 400% tax deduction on the first S$50,000 of qualifying AI spend in each Year of Assessment, for YA2027 and YA2028. Only the AI part of a subscription counts, and spend covered by a government grant does not. This table is the starting point for your tax adviser, who decides what qualifies and makes the claim.
| Item | Spend | AI part | How we split it | May qualify |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Microsoft 365 Copilot Business | S$13,200 | 100% | Separate AI licence | S$13,200 |
| ChatGPT Business | S$9,360 | 100% | AI service | S$9,360 |
| OpenAI API (payslip assistant) | S$9,780 | 100% | AI service, billed by use | S$9,780 |
| Notion Business | S$6,240 | 50% | Business plan price minus the Plus plan, which does not include full Notion AI | S$3,120 |
| Claude Team | S$3,120 | 100% | AI service | S$3,120 |
| Grammarly Pro | S$1,920 | 100% | AI writing service; ask your adviser to confirm | S$1,920 |
| GitHub Copilot Business | S$1,800 | 100% | AI service | S$1,800 |
| Reimbursed personal plans: Otter, Perplexity, Cursor, ChatGPT Plus | S$7,224 | 100% | AI services, but the plans are in employees’ names | Ask your adviser |
| Canva Teams | S$1,560 | — | Has AI tools but no separate AI price | Ask your adviser |
| Copilot Chat, Zoom AI Companion, Xero AI features | — | — | Included at no extra cost | — |
| Total that may qualify | Cap: S$50,000 for YA2027 | S$42,300 | ||
Management told us that none of these costs was covered by a government grant. Two lines are left for your adviser: the reimbursed personal plans, which are in employees’ names, and Canva Teams (S$1,560), which has AI tools but no separate AI price. Rules: IRAS e-Tax Guide on the Enterprise Innovation Scheme (3rd edition, 31 Aug 2026), Annex F. Ask your adviser to confirm the final rules before you claim.
Part 6 of 7
90-day plan
18 actions, each with an owner and a date: 17 within 90 days and one at the Copilot renewal in March. Together they close every finding in Part 2.
First 30 days
| # | Action | Owner | By | Findings | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | This week, with your lawyer: assess whether client data has been exposed through personal AI accounts and the shared key, decide which clients to tell, and agree how to correct the March questionnaire answer. Save the OpenAI logs and file list before anything is deleted. | CEO, COO (DPO) | 30 Oct 2026 | 3.1, 4.2, 7.1 | Legal position clear |
| 2 | Replace the OpenAI key today and set spend alerts with a cap on automatic top-ups. Once the logs are saved, delete the test payslip files and make two company admins the owners. | Tech lead | 30 Oct 2026 | 4.2, 2.6 | High risk closed |
| 3 | Remove the email assistant’s access. Require IT approval for any app that asks for mail, files or calendar access. | IT lead | 5 Nov 2026 | 4.1 | High risk closed |
| 4 | Reduce Grammarly to 3 seats before it renews. | Finance manager | 13 Nov 2026 | 2.3 | Saves S$1,344 a year |
| 5 | Offer company seats to anyone using a personal AI account: idle ChatGPT seats to payroll operations, 5 idle Copilot seats to accounting, Copilot Chat for everyone else. Stop reimbursing personal AI plans from December. Owners of meeting recorders delete client-call recordings after saving the notes the client file needs. | COO, Finance manager | 25 Nov 2026 | 3.1, 3.3, 2.2, 5.1 | Saves S$7,224 a year |
| 6 | Publish the client-data rule and block NRIC numbers on unapproved AI sites. | COO (DPO), IT lead | 25 Nov 2026 | 3.1 | High risk closed |
| 7 | Limit the three payroll SharePoint sites to the payroll team. | IT lead | 25 Nov 2026 | 3.2 | — |
| 8 | Route the payslip assistant’s answers to payroll operations for approval, and log them. | Tech lead, Head of payroll operations | 25 Nov 2026 | 4.3 | — |
| 9 | Send the client an accurate answer about AI use, as your lawyer advises. | CEO | 25 Nov 2026 | 7.1 | High risk closed |
Days 31–90
| # | Action | Owner | By | Findings | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | Switch Claude Team to annual billing for 7 seats. | Tech lead | 4 Dec 2026 | 2.5 | Saves S$936 a year |
| 11 | Name the AI owner. Adopt the AI policy, the approved-tools list and the register, and add AI to the data protection policy. Train every employee by 15 January. | CEO, COO (DPO) | 15 Dec 2026 | 6.1, 3.4, 1.1, 1.2 | — |
| 12 | File the data processing terms and a one-page record for each approved vendor. Test one alternative model for the payslip assistant. | COO (DPO), Tech lead | 15 Dec 2026 | 7.3, 7.4 | — |
| 13 | Renew ChatGPT Business at 27 seats. | Finance manager | 5 Jan 2027 | 2.4 | Saves S$936 a year |
| 14 | Compare handling times in two operations teams for the 30 days before and after they move to company AI seats. | Head of payroll operations | 15 Jan 2027 | 5.2 | — |
| 15 | Finish the client answer pack: 12 common questions with answers, evidence and one person who checks them. | COO | 15 Jan 2027 | 7.2 | — |
| 16 | Send Part 5 to your tax adviser. | Finance manager | 22 Jan 2027 | 2.7 | — |
| 17 | Send Zoom summaries to the host only. Decide, tool by tool, on the AI features built into your software. | IT lead | 22 Jan 2027 | 3.5, 1.3 | — |
Next decision
| # | Action | Owner | By | Findings | Effect |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 18 | Renew Microsoft 365 Copilot at 22 seats instead of 40. | Finance manager, IT lead | 15 Feb 2027 | 2.1 | Saves S$5,940 a year |
Part 7 of 7
How we did this audit
How the audit ran
Ten working days, 12 Oct to 23 Oct 2026. Kestrel Lane Payroll’s managers spent about two and a half hours on approving read-only access and two 30-minute interviews; every employee was asked to spend five minutes on the anonymous survey.
What we read
- Microsoft 365: app approvals and permissions, sign-in logs, Copilot usage report and SharePoint sharing settings, through a read-only app your administrator approved
- Xero: 12 months of bills and expense claims, read-only
- Corporate card statements (CSV export)
- ChatGPT Business and Claude Team: member and activity exports from the admin panels
- GitHub: Copilot seat list, read-only
- OpenAI: organisation and billing settings, usage and cost export, project file names
- Helpdesk: ticket counts and handling times (CSV export)
- Anonymous staff survey: 61 of 80 staff replied (76%), giving their team but not their name
- Two 30-minute interviews: CEO with COO, and IT lead with tech lead
- Documents: Data Protection Policy (2023), client contract template, two client AI questionnaires
What we did not collect: prompts, chats, emails, recordings or the contents of files. We worked from names, roles, amounts, dates, settings and permission lists.
What we could not check
- Whether a data breach has occurred: that is a legal assessment for you and your lawyer (Part 6, action 1).
- Zoom: admin access was not given. We used the invoice and one user’s settings.
- Personal AI accounts: their settings and contents are private. We relied on the survey.
- The payslip assistant’s accuracy: no log of its answers exists yet (finding 4.3).
- 19 staff did not answer the survey, so shadow AI may be undercounted.
How we score
- High
- Could lead to a data breach, a loss above S$10,000 or the loss of a client. Act within 30 days.
- Medium
- Weakens control or wastes money. Fix within 90 days, or at the next renewal where seats can change only then.
- Low
- Housekeeping. Fix at the next review or renewal.
Savings are yearly amounts at current prices and seat counts, and each starts on the date shown in Part 4. One-off costs, such as the August API spike, are never counted. Amounts are in Singapore dollars; in this sample, US-dollar invoices are converted at S$1.30 per US$1. The breach assessment in Part 6, action 1 is a legal question: we point to it, your lawyer answers it.
Rules and frameworks
- Personal Data Protection Act 2012 (PDPA): s.12, s.24, s.26, s.26C
- PDPC Advisory Guidelines on Use of Personal Data in Generative AI (20 Jul 2026)
- IMDA Model AI Governance Framework for Agentic AI (v1.5, 2026)
- CSA Guidelines on Securing AI Systems (2024)
- MAS Guidelines on AI Risk Management (7 Oct 2026): a benchmark here, as they apply to financial institutions
- ISO/IEC 42001:2023, Annex A
- NIST AI Risk Management Framework 1.0
- IRAS e-Tax Guide: Enterprise Innovation Scheme (3rd edition, 31 Aug 2026), Annex F
This report compares the company’s practice with these rules and frameworks. It is not a certification, a legal opinion or tax advice. PDPC, MAS and IRAS decide how their rules apply.